When we looked at the FDA’s expected ban of menthol cigarettes earlier this week, I raised several questions about both the efficacy of such a plan in terms of promoting better health and the way that the subject immediately became the focus of racial controversy. Thus far, the only arguments I’ve heard in terms of the health benefits of such a ban seem like fairly weak tea. But when it comes to the racialized nature of the debate, it turns out that I wasn’t the only one who found the descriptions being used to be offputting. The American Civil Liberties Union has already weighed in on the subject, saying that the menthol ban will “disproportionately affect communities of color.” While I tend to agree that turning this into a race-based argument seems to be silly at a minimum and potentially offensive, I’m not sure that the ACLU is coming at this question from the same perspective as I was. (Daily Wire)
The Biden administration is expected to announce a proposal to ban menthol cigarettes later this week, a move that some groups have been wanting for a long time, while others say it will lead to more incarceration and negatively impact communities of color…
The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) and other groups sent a letter to the Biden administration earlier this week, pushing back against a potential ban on menthol cigarettes. The groups said that such a move would “Disproportionately Impact People and Communities of Color, Trigger Criminal Penalties, and Lead to Negative Interactions with Law Enforcement.” The letter pointed to the cases of Eric Garner, Michael Brown, and George Floyd as situations where cigarettes were involved, adding that “well-intentioned efforts to continue to reduce death and disease from tobacco products must avoid solutions that will create yet another reason for armed police to engage citizens on the street based on pretext or conduct that does not pose a threat to public safety.” The groups argued that a ban on menthol cigarettes “would disproportionately impact communities of color, result in criminalization of the market, and exacerbate mass incarceration.”
At first glance, I was under the impression that the ACLU was saying that removing menthol cigarettes from the market would produce a racially disproportionate effect on Black communities because the FDA would be taking away a product that’s overwhelmingly popular among smokers in communities of color. That would be a rather odd argument because you would, in effect, be saying that the proposed rule would deprive Black people of a greater opportunity to come down with cancer. But reading through their letter, that’s really not what they’re saying.
The ACLU’s claim is that the proposed ban would criminalize yet another non-violent activity, increasing police interaction with the Black community further. They go so far as to invoke the names of George Floyd and Eric Garner. While the group is coming at it from a different angle, that’s really not all that different from the enforcement question I raised in my previous article. As soon as you ban those brands of cigarettes, a black market will immediately emerge for people to import menthol cigarettes, probably from Mexico, and sell them illegally. (Canada banned methol cigarettes years ago.) That means that somebody is going to have to enforce the ban and arrest people who are smuggling the cigarettes and issue tickets to the people in possession of a pack.
Yes, We Need Your Help
I hate being “that guy” who asks people to donate because I think our conservative news network is so crucial, but here I am…
When I left my cushy corporate job in 2017, I did so knowing that my family would have to make sacrifices. But I couldn’t continue to watch the nation slip into oblivion and was inspired by President Trump’s willingness to fight the good fight even at his own personal expense. What I didn’t realize then is that conservative media would be so heavily attacked, canceled, and defunded that the sacrifices would be extreme.
Many in this nation are struggling right now even though we weren’t struggling just a few years ago. I’m not alone. But I wake up every morning and operate the sites we’ve been able to build because there’s really no other choice. I refuse to be beholden to Big Tech like so many other conservative news outlets, which is why you won’t see Google ads here. With that said, it’s often challenging to pay the bills and it’s even harder to expand so we can get the America First message out to a wider audience.
The economic downturn has forced me to make a plea for help. Between cancel culture, lockdowns, and diminishing ad revenue, we need financial assistance in order to continue to spread the truth. We ask all who have the means, please donate through our Giving Fuel. Your generosity is what keeps these sites running and allows us to expand our reach so the truth can get to the masses. We’ve had great success in growing but we know we can do more with your assistance.
We currently operate:
- NOQ Report
- Conservative Playlist
- Uncanceled News
- Based Underground
- Five other conservative news sites
I would even be willing to entertain investments and partnerships at this stage. I’ve turned them down in the past because editorial purity is extremely important. I’ll turn them down again if anyone wants us to start supporting RINOs or avoid “taboo” topics like voter fraud, vaccines, or transgender supremacy. But I’d talk to fellow America First patriots who want to help any (or all) of our 10 news sites. Hit me up at jdrucker (at) substack (dot) com if you’re interested.
For those who have the means and just want to help keep the mission of spreading a conservative, Christian message to the nation, please consider a generous donation.